Computer-Aided Decision-Making for the Highest Sustainable Reuse of Historic Buildings
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.60923/issn.2612-0496/19559Keywords:
Preventive conservation, Adaptive reuse, decision-making, Highest Sustainable Reuse, MAROHBAbstract
The adaptive reuse policy aims to extend the functional life of the historic building in a way that suits its physical age. Recently, computer software has been utilized in decision-making processes as an assistant and accelerator to attain the best results. This paper seeks to create a program to achieve the Highest Sustainable Reuse - HSR of the historic building. The software is created by specifying two categories of urban and architectural requirements and restrictions. The first relates to the characteristics, capabilities, and limitations of the historic building, while the second describes the needs and conditions of the proposed function. By performing an algorithmic comparison, the program is able to provide percentages for a set of proposed functions based on the case study. The paper concluded the effectiveness of the proposed methodology by conducting it on the historic Al- Barood Khanah building in Mosul.
References
Alallaf, Emad Hani . 2013. “The 4res Procedure for Preserving the Built Heritage Of Old Mosul A Sustainable Conservation Policy.” The Second Engineering Conference for the Golden Jubilee of Engineering College - University of Mosul. Mosul, Iraq.
Al-Allaf, Imad Hani , Ahmed Youssef Al-Omari, and Mumtaz Hazem Al-Diwaji. 2019. “Alternatives to the reconstruction of Al-Hadbaa Minaret in Old Mosul.” Sulaimani Journal for Engineering Sciences 6 (2): 13-24.
De Silva, G.D.R., B.A.K.S. Perera, and M.N.N. Rodrigo. 2019. “Adaptive reuse of buildings: the case of Sri Lanka.” Journal of Financial Management of Property and Construction 24 (1): 79-96.
Islami, Seyed Gholamreza , Davood Dehghan, and Hasan Sadeghi Naeini. 2016. “A Model Development to Adaptive Reuse of Iranian Qajar Houses: An Approach to Sociocultural Concept (A Case: Nasir Al-Din Mirza House).” American Journal of Civil Engineering and Architecture 4 (3): 84-89.
Kip , Markus , and Heike Oevermann. 2022. “Neighbourhood Revitalisation and Heritage Conservation through Adaptive Reuse: Assessing Instruments for Commoning.” The Historic Environment: Policy & Practice 13 (2): 242-266.
Marika , Gaballo, Mecca Beatrice , and Abastante Francesca. 2021. “Adaptive Reuse and Sustainability Protocols in Italy: Relationship with Circular Economy.” Sustainability 13 (14): 8077.
Othman, Ayman Ahmed Ezzat , and Heba Elsaay. 2018. “Adaptive reuse: an innovative approach for generating sustainable values for historic buildings in developing countries.” Organization, technology & management in construction: an international journal (Organization, technology & management in construction: an international journal) 10 (1): 1704-1718.
Pinto, Maria Rita , Stefania De Medici, Carla Senia, Katia Fabbricatti, and Pasquale De Toro. 2017. “Building reuse: multi-criteria assessment for compatible design.” Int. J. Des. Sci. Technol (International Journal of Design Sciences and Technology) 22: 165-193.
Spina, Lucia Della . 2020. “Adaptive Sustainable Reuse for Cultural Heritage: A Multiple Criteria Decision Aiding Approach Supporting Urban Development Processes.” Sustainability 12 (4): 1363.
Tan, Yongtao, Liyin Shen , and Craig Langston. 2015. “A Quantitative Approach for Identifying Adaptive Reuse Option for Industrial Buildings.” Proceedings of the 19th International Symposium on Advancement of Construction Management and Real Estate. Springer Berlin Heidelberg: Proceedings of the 19th International Symposium on Advancement of Construction Management and Real Estate. Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg. 505–495.
Vehbi , Beser Oktay , Ka ˘gan Günçe , and Aminreza Iranmanesh . 2021. “Multi-Criteria Assessment for Defining Compatible New Use: Old Administrative Hospital, Kyrenia, Cyprus.” Sustainability 13 (4): 1922.
Wilkinson , Sara J. , Hilde Remøy , and Craig Langston. 2014. Sustainable Building Adaptation Innovations in Decision-making. United Kingdom: John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
Act No. 645. 2005. National Heritage Act. Malaysia: The Commissioner of Law Revision, Malaysia.
Aigwia, Itohan Esther , Jason Ingham, Robyn Phipps, and Olga Filippova. 2020. “Identifying parameters for a performance-based framework: Towards prioritising underutilised historical buildings for adaptive reuse in New Zealand.” Cities 102: 102756.
Al Diwaji, Saeed. 1982. History of Mosul. 1. Mosul - Iraq: Iraqi Scientific Academy.
Alhojaly, Rawan Abdullatif , Abeer Abdulaziz Alawad, and Noura Abdulrahman Ghabra. 2022. “A Proposed Model of Assessing the Adaptive Reuse of Heritage Buildings in Historic Jeddah.” Buildings 12 (4): 406.
Aljumaa, Ahmed Qasim. 2020. The old Arab city of Mosul is undergoing reconstruction and development. Mosul-Iraq: Mosul House. Accessed 9 1, 2023. https://www.baytalmosul.com/.
Avrami, Erica , Randall Mason, and Marta de la Torre. 2000. Values and Heritage Conservation. Research Report, Los Angeles: The Getty Conservation Institute, Los Angeles.
Barakat, Armange Ismael, and Wafaa Anwar Goriel. 2019. “Factors Affecting the Adaptive Reuse Process for Historical Buildings in Kurdistan Region An analytical study of Qubahan School as Historical Case Study.” Sulaimani Journal for Engineering Sciences 6 (3): 29-46.
Bertolin, Chiara, and Arian Loli. 2018. “Sustainable interventions in historic buildings: A developing decision making tool.” Journal of Cultural Heritage 34: 291-302.
Brooker, Graeme , and Sally Stone. 2018. Re-readings: 2: Interior Architecture and the Principles of Remodelling Existing Buildings. London: RIBA.
Chandrakar, Shreya , and Sandeep Singh. 2022. “Adaptive reuse of heritage building.” INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF CREATIVE RESEARCH THOUGHTS - IJCRT (IJCRT.ORG) 10 (5): c330-c336.
Department, Buildings . 2019. Practice Guidebook for Adaptive Re-use of and Alteration and Addition Works to Heritage Buildings 2012. 2019 Edition. Hong Kong: Buildings Department.
Djebbour, Imane , and Ratiba Wided Biara. 2020. “The challenge of adaptive reuse towards the sustainability of heritage buildings.” International Journal of Conservation Science 11 (2): 519-530.
El borolosy, Lobna Abd el aziz . 2022. “Use multi-criteria analysis MCDM, to determine the most appropriate funding for the adaptive reuse of heritage buildings (Case study of the Champollion Palace(.” International Journal of Multidisciplinary Studies in Architecture and Cultural Heritage 5 (2): 1 – 29.
Elsorady, Dalia Abdelaziz . 2014. “Assessment of the compatibility of new uses for heritage buildings: The example of Alexandria National Museum, Alexandria, Egypt.” Journal of Cultural Heritage 15 15 (5): 511-521.
Eltarabishi, Fatma , Omar Hassan Omar, Imad Alsyouf, and Maamar Bettayeb. 2020. “Multi-Criteria Decision Making Methods And Their Applications– A Literature Review.” the International Conference on Industrial Engineering and Operations Management,Dubai, UAE. Dubai.
Farjami , Elnaz , and Özlem Olgaç Türker. 2021. “The Extraction of Prerequisite Criteria for Environmentally Certified Adaptive Reuse of Heritage Buildings.” Sustainability (Sustainability) 13 (6): 3536.
Feilden, Bernard M. 2007. Conservation of historic buildings. Third edition. Rome: Elsevier 1994, 2003.
Garzillo, Cristina , Intza Balenciaga, Ane Izulain, Talía Rangil Escribano, and Allison Wildman. 2020. Adaptive Reuse of Cultural Heritage (An Examination of Circular Governance Models from 16 International Case Studies). Synthesis, California: ICLEI Europe.
Haroun , Hebatu-Allah Abdul Fattah , Ali Fouad Bakr, and Asmaa El-Sayed Hasan. 2019. “Multi-criteria decision making for adaptive reuse of heritage buildings: Aziza Fahmy Palace, Alexandria, Egypt.” Alexandria engineering journal (Elsevier B.V. on behalf of Faculty of Engineering, Alexandria University) 58 (2): 467-478.
Hegazi , Yasmine Sabry, Heidi Ahmed Shalaby , and Mady A. A. Mohamed. 2021. “Adaptive Reuse Decisions for Historic Buildings in Relation to Energy Efficiency and Thermal Comfort—Cairo Citadel, a Case Study from Egypt.” Sustainability 13 (19): 10531.
ICOMOS. 2015. Principles for the Conservation of Heritage Sites in China. China: the State Administration of Cultural Heritage.
ICOMOS, Burra Charter. 1999. The Australia ICOMOS Charter for Places of Cultural Significance. Australia: Australia ICOMOS.
Institute of Architects, Royal Australian. 2004. Adaptive reuse : preserving our past, building our future. Australia: Department of the Environment and Heritage.
Jokilehto, Jukka . 1999. A History of Architectural Conservation. England, UK: Routledge.
Joudifar, Farnaz , and Özlem Olgaç Türker. 2020. “A ‘Reuse Projection Framework’ Based on Othello’s Citadel and Cultural Tourism.” The Historic Environment: Policy & Practice 11 (2-3): 202-231.
Miran, Fenk D. , and Husein A. Husein. 2023. “Introducing a Conceptual Model for Assessing the Present State of Preservation in Heritage Buildings: Utilizing Building Adaptation as an Approach.” Buildings 13 (4): 859.
Misra, Rahul . 2015. Introduction to Management- Principles of Management. India: KMRO.
Mosul, University. 1991. Mosul Civilizational Encyclopedia. 1,2,3,4. Mosul-Iraq: Ibn Al-Atheer House for Printing and Publishing.
Mutal, S. 2015. “Adaptive reuse for the future development of the historic centres, some thoughts and considerations.” Handout 7: 1-7.
Okba, Ehab M., and Mohga E. Embaby. 2013. “Sustainability and Heritage Buildings.” International Journal of Engineering Research & Technology (IJERT) 2 (8): 1682-1690.
Parpas, Despo, and Andreas Savvides. 2018. “Sustainable-driven adaptive reuse: Evaluation of criteria in a multi-attribute framework.” WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment 217: 29-37.
Ribera, Federica, Antonio Nesticò, Pasquale Cucco, and Gabriella Maselli. 2019. “A multicriteria approach to identify the Highest and Best Use for historical buildings.” Journal of Cultural Heritage 41: 166-177.
Sawtak, Irfaa. 2023. Irfaa Sawtak . 1 27. Accessed 9 28, 2023. https://www.facebook.com/irfaasawtakonline/posts/5991810254206361/?locale=hi_IN&paipv=0&eav=AfZJQ3tJKz4uh4f-Yox2lRx4JjAVLoU_hG58yv-Xt0zcs4MwNEb10U0csbIvG1o_vnQ&_rdr.
Shakya , Kripa , and Sudarshan Raj Tiwari . 2021. “Sustainability Assessment of Adaptive Reuse Buildings in Kathmandu - A study of three cases in Patan.” Proceedings of 10th IOE Graduate Conference . Kirtipur,Nepal.
Tarrad, Mohannad, and Salam Mtawea husban. 2021. “The Creation of Guidelines for Adaptive Reuse of Heritage Buildings in Jordan, Case Study Palace of the Ali Alkaid Basha (Jordan).” Architecture and Modern Information Technologies 3 (56): 64–78.
Yildirim, Mücahit . 2012. “Assessment of the decision-making process for re-use of a historical asset: The example of Diyarbakir Hasan Pasha Khan, Turkey.” Journal of cultural heritage 13 (4): 379-388.
Yıldırım, Mücahit , and Gizem Turan. 2012. “Sustainable development in historic areas: Adaptive re-use challenges in traditional houses in Sanliurfa, Turkey.” Habitat International 36 (4): 493-503.
Zhang, Yan, and Qi Zhang. 2023. “A model approach for post evaluation of adaptive reuse of architectural heritage: a case study of Beijing central axis historical buildings.” Heritage Science 11 (1): 1-17.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2024 Suroor Abdulghafoor Jasim, Emad Hani Ismaeel
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
